Add the PWI Blog to Your Google Homepage

Add to Google Reader or Homepage

Tuesday, July 31, 2012

CM Punk "Turn" Needs Teeth

Is CM Punk a "good guy," a "bad guy," or a "tweener"? For the entire week following his historic attack of The Rock on the 1,000th Episode of Raw, I think most WWE fans just assumed the logical answer was #2. Not me. After all, wasn’t John Cena, himself, delivering his finisher to "The Great One" just a few months ago?

Maybe I missed the entire point of what Punk was saying throughout last night’s follow-up Raw, but to me he just came off more as a bitter fan favorite than anything. It was as if he had a sudden epiphany that he’d been disrespected by the WWE matchmakers, who continually failed to put him in a single pay-per-view main event since winning the title in his current run. Look it up. He has yet to close a PPV since winning the title at last year's Survivor Series.

More importantly, in spite of all his anger and all his jealousy directed at his WWE peers, there is one all-important group to which Punk has stayed loyal … and I think they’ll respect him even more for it.
He has yet to turn on the fans.

Over the past week, I’ve had a lot of people tell me that this angle - Punk "turning" – is the 2012 version of WWE’s big summertime angle, in the vein of Nexus, Mr. McMahon’s limo explosion, the "pipe bomb," and Hornswoggle’s revelation as a McMahon. I don’t see it.

Yes, CM Punk attacked The Rock on July 23, and followed that up with an assault on both Cena and Show this week. Can you really blame him? Is anything that he said untrue about Rock coming in for the occasional payday and taking the spotlight off of Punk and so many other guys who no doubt deserve more attention than they get? And if it were Cena sitting at commentary and Punk thrown through him, does anyone really envision Cena just getting up, straightening his cap, and continuing to stay out the match he was just thrust into?

Here’s what I do see. I see a very successful WWE champion. I see a man who has, in many ways, surpassed John Cena in terms of notoriety among his peers and fans alike. It’s like CM Punk has been trying so hard for so long to be that Cena main-event alternative that WWE fans have been craving for so long … and he’s just now realizing there is a ceiling to his ability to ever really be that alternative.

I don’t like this year’s Punk "turn," if it even is one. Ironically, though, it’s not because my anger is directed at him. Rather, WWE’s corporate machine is the villain who has painted Punk as a bad guy just for continuing to do what he has for nearly all of his career - good, bad, or otherwise - and stand up strongly for all that he believes. Last year, CM Punk was a "good guy" with a chip on his shoulder, taking on stars such as John Cena, Triple-H, and Alberto Del Rio. Now I’m supposed to think that same chip that made him the most popular wrestler in the company has transformed him into a heinous baddie, when many of his opponents are still the same? This turn doesn’t have any teeth, because Punk SHOULD be - and I suspect really is - a sympathetic figure.

And without any teeth, all WWE can do is continue feeding us mush.

Brady Hicks
PWI Contributing Writer


Tony Laplume said...

I would still urge caution in judging Punk on this turn. He's basically reiterating the problems he spoke of in his infamous pipe bomb. If he wasn't a heel then, he isn't now, either, but the fans now have a choice to see him that way, because he's rebelled in the biggest way possible, against one of the biggest stars in company history.

It's both the same and totally different than what John Cena was doing earlier this year. There's a lot of ego involved, but where Cena can boast a strong and loyal following for be another of the company's centerpieces, Punk is the guy who lives what Cena really only preaches, living and breathing for professional wrestling.

In other words, when Punk says he's Best in the World, he has a completely different meaning than Cena might have, or what The Rock has lived off of for years. The Rock is billed as the Most Electrifying Man of All of Entertainment. Punk isn't here to be an entertainer. He's here to do what he loves, and he doesn't hide behind the reaction of the audience. Very much like The Rock, he does live and die on the reaction of the audience. Cena pointedly said he doesn't care, so long as the fans are passionate.

Where The Rock needs the fans to be on his side, Punk has progressed to a point in his career where he doesn't have to pander anymore. The fans love him for who he is, good or bad. That's an interesting dynamic, an incredible hook, and something worth thinking about in the next few months.

bradyhicks said...

Well said, Tony!